Decision Making as Output and Bounded Rationality

  The classical economics theories proceed on the assumption of rational agents. Rationality implies the economic agents undertake actions or exercise choices based on the cost-benefit analysis they undertake. The assumption further posits that there exists no information asymmetry and thus the agent is aware of all the costs and benefits associated with the choice he or she has exercised. The behavioral school contested the decision stating the decisions in practice are often irrational. Implied there is a continuous departure from rationality. Rationality in the views of the behavioral school is more an exception to the norm rather a rule. The past posts have discussed the limitations of this view by the behavioral school. Economics has often posited rationality in the context in which the choices are exercised rather than theoretical abstract view of rational action. Rational action in theory seems to be grounded in zero restraint situation yet in practice, there are numerous restra

India's Lowest Cricket Test Scores

 

The Adelaide test has seen a new low for India. The Indian team in the race for the World Test Championship victory has been shot down for 36 in its second innings thus its lowest score in Test cricket. The previous dubious distinction was held by Ajit Wadekar’s side of 1974 when it was dismissed for 42 at Lords. It too incidentally came in the second innings. As an aside, Indians were known to make great comebacks in second innings in the past. There was a saying why doesn’t India play the second innings first. In the current test, India did go with a sizeable advantage into the second innings. In a low scoring test, a first innings lead of even 50 would be quite handy and chasing something like 200+ in the fourth innings would anyway be difficult no matter the batting strength. Yet India handed the match on the platter with a rather timid display against some fine bowling from the Australians. No pitch would obviously be 36 all out pitch and it must be to the batsman who miserably failed to make the mark. In this context, it would be interesting to dig into the past into some of the India’s lowest scores in test cricket.

 

India was visiting England in 1974 with lot of hope. They had won the previous series in 1971 and later followed up with a home series win in 1973. Yet this tour was anything but happy. The despair both on and off the field was perhaps too much. In the second test England ran up with a score of 629 and they bowled out India for 302 enforcing a follow on. What followed was some Old Arnold swing which led India to collapse to 42 all out. Eknath Solkar remained unbeaten on 18, the only double figure score in the innings. Sunil Gavaskar would later remark that all England needed to bowl two good deliveries one to dismiss him and another to dismiss GR Vishwanath and the rest of the batting would fold up in no time. In fact, that was very characteristic of the previous test.

 

In 1947-48, India visited Australia for the first time and incidentally it was the first series post-independence. Indians were perhaps overawed by Bradman’s Australians which had Lindwall, Miller, Toshack in the attack. The first test was in Brisbane Gabba and Australia batting first declared at 382/8. Indias were completely outplayed getting bowled out for 58 in the first innings. Skipper Lala Amarnath made 22 while Vijay Hazare and Chandu Sarwate too crossed the double figures. Indians asked to follow on did only marginally better getting bowled out for 98. The famed batting line up which used to amass runs in the domestic first class season was undone very quickly on the bouncy tracks of the Gabba. Later in the series, India went to the final test at Melbourne seeking to restore pride with series already decided. Australia ran up to 575/8 before declaration. India did play well but folded out at 331 with Aussies deciding to enforce the follow on. India simply could not handle the Aussie bowling in the second innings getting all out for 67, incidentally with four players reaching double figures. The series was lost 4-0.

 

India toured England in 1952 and a debutant Fred Truman had them running at 0/4. This perhaps is still the maximum wickets lost in a test match before opening the mark. As if it was not enough, India had to face more trouble in the third test at Old Trafford Manchester. India was dismissed for 58, equalling the previous lowest mentioned above. In fact, of the 58 made by the team, the two Vijays Manjrekar and Hazare made 38 of them. This was after England declared at 347/9 in their first innings. The second innings again proved marginally better with India dismissed for 82 with Hemu Adhikari top scoring at 27. Incidentally, this is the only occasion till date that a side has been bowled out twice in a test match on a single calendar day. The scores of 58 in both these tests discussed above were to remain the lowest till India broke the dubious record with 42 in 1974.

 

In 1996, India travelled to South Africa for their second tour to the country. It was a back to back series with India winning 2-1, a three test series at home. It was for the first time that South Africa had lost a test series since their readmission to test cricket in 1992. Billed  as revenge series, India dismissed South Africa for 223 but found the South African pace bowlers led by Alan Donald and Shaun Pollock too hot to handle folding out for 100. South Africa again were restricted to 259, but the chase was too tall to handle. Yet no one expected India to literally collapse. Barring Rahul Dravid with an unbeaten 27, no other Indian batsman could handle the pace on the bouncy track at Kingsmead and folded for 66.

 

In 1987, India hosted the West Indies at home with the first test being in Ferozeshah Kotla in Delhi. Against the West Indian pace quartet, Indians were dismissed for mere 75 on the opening day with Arun Lal top scoring at 20. Indians did well to restrict West Indies and later set a challenging 276 for fourth innings win. The West Indies won the test thanks to Viv Richards century, and it remains the highest successful chase by a visiting team in India. Coming to recent times, India was dismissed for 76 against South Africa in Ahmedabad in 2008 with Irfan Pathan, skipper MS Dhoni and the extras adding some 54 runs of this total.

 

In all India have been dismissed on twenty two occasions for less than hundred. Seventeen of those test matches have ended in a defeat for India. There have been five instances of drawn match. The lowest score in a drawn match was 83 against New Zealand in Mohali in 1999. It was basically through 505/3 declared in the second innings against a relatively inexperienced New Zealand bowling and hundreds by Tendulkar and Dravid that enabled India to save the match. The lowest scores in test matches by Indian sides are available here. The current post seeks to posit the today’s performance against historical background. The Australians outplayed India in the third innings and that was perhaps all that mattered to the test and perhaps to the series as well.

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Decision Making as Output and Bounded Rationality

The Chicken-Egg Conundrum of Economics

A Note on Supply-Demand Dynamics